GregHowley.com

A New Spam Animal

April 10, 2007 -

Long has been my battle with spam here at Blog of Wonder. Between writing and rewriting my personalized spam filter and manually deleting the ones that slip through, I've done pretty good job of preventing comment spam. I hope that if my legit commenters ever hit the filter on a legit comment, they'll email me to let me know the details so I can tweak things.

But recently, two different types of comment spam have stumped me. Firstly, I've gotten a few spam comments on old old posts. As you may know, I've got rules in the server-side code which prevent comments on any topics not currently on the front page. But somehow, I've gotten 2 or 3 spam comments on blog posts from over a year ago. I don't know how in the heck that happens. I've just been manually deleting them, but the phenomenon perplexes me.

Secondly, an animal a bit more insidious than the last: manually-written comments which seem to pertain to the post I've written, and yet which are somewhat inane and truly contribute nothing. Normally, I'd just qualify these as stupid rather than as spam. But when they contain a link to a site obviously trying to boost its pagerank, a site which is by no means a personal site, it's got to be categorized as spam. This has happened 2 or 3 times now, all by the same guy. I left the most recent one simply as an example, although I removed the link to his site. Check out this comment by "register damage". See what I mean? What do you think?

Comments on A New Spam Animal
 
Comment Tue, April 10 - 1:25 PM by Glenn
This seem like comment left by mixture of caveman/'english as 4th or 5th language'. o well it seem like dumbness. I'm glade I could chuckle with its stupidity-esque-ness.
 
Comment Wed, April 11 - 9:09 AM by Brandon
Me likey ur game. Ur site is nice. lol. Egad. I can't even do this in jest. It hurts my brain too much.
 
Comment Wed, April 11 - 7:50 PM by pmd
I'm thinking some machine 'read' your blog and posted some 'canned' text to make it appear as if a person had read your blog and responded. I'm wondering if this is in any way related to the spam I'm getting in my inbox.

"The ARTROM GALLERY GUILD in Rome, Italy. It's also a good deal for Guldeniz.
PHP-Nuke comes with absolutely no warranty, for details, see the license.
Please contact your system administrator to report this fault. If you are the system administrator, please click here. If confirmed by Guinness World Records, the Amazon swim will be the fourth time Strel has broken the world record for long-distance swimming. See an internet version in Chinese."
 
Comment Wed, April 11 - 8:04 PM by pmd
Turing Test!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_Test
 
Comment Thu, April 12 - 8:48 PM by tagger
I see no reason to drag Alan Turing into what is a fairly simple-minded affair.

Any half-decent computer program can parse bLog postings, puke out "relevent" comments and insert links to boost their Google scores, right?

 
Comment Fri, April 13 - 7:15 PM by pmd
But isn't this what this is... A computer generated response intended to make the blogger question if he's offending a reader (by censoring a post) or filtering out computer generated spam?

As far as my original Turing post... Greg's homebrew blogware censored/misquoted me, and I just didn't say anything about it until now. The original post said something similar to *headslap* Turing Test! *headslap*... but they were filtered out as HTML Tags and were taken out instead of being treated as literal.

 
Comment Mon, April 16 - 7:14 PM by Greg
Well, this guy just commented again. So I blocked any comments with his domain name in the URL. Screw you, mister Register Damage!
 
Comment Wed, April 18 - 2:31 AM by Magus2
Was it the same type of message this time. This seems like a pretty gray area to me. I mean you are free to delete any thing you want obviously, but we should feel sure it's just spamming right? Most spam is so much more obvious, I haven't had problems with blocking it so far.
 
Comment Wed, April 18 - 3:10 PM by Kate
Bizarre. It's like... manual spam. Like a blog spam-troll. Or somethin'.
 
Comment Wed, April 18 - 3:52 PM by Greg
Hi Kate! Good to see folks I know in real life here. And that's exactly what it is: manual spam.