I brought my car in this morning just to have the tires rotated. I know it's been slightly over the recommended 10,000 miles since I last rotated them, so I figured I was being good by bringing it in now. I want to keep my car in good shape, since I'm in the car two hours every day. But a few hours ago, I got a call - "Your tires don't need to be rotated. They need to be replaced." Crap.
Turns out that I've been keeping my tires overinflated, and they wore badly. They each say "max pressure 44psi", so I inflated them all to 44psi, thinking that was the thing to do. Oh no. The tire guy recommended 32psi, given that it's generally just me in the car. He showed me a little guide sheet on the inside of my fuel tank lid.
So now I'm out $170 for two new tires. Maybe I'll be able to make it up hills when it snows now. You can bet I'll be paying closer attention to my tire pressure, and probably rotating them every 3000 miles now. Hopefully this can save you some grief. (and money)